Skip to main content

Blue or Pink (and Everything In Between): Navigating Gender Discovery Emotions After Infertility

  


As your pregnancy progresses, another significant and often eagerly anticipated milestone might arrive: finding out the sex of your baby. Whether it’s through early genetic screening like NIPT or during that detailed mid-pregnancy anatomy scan, the moment you learn whether you’re expecting a boy or a girl (or perhaps you’re choosing to keep it a surprise!) can be filled with excitement and help make your growing baby feel even more real. It allows for name discussions to get serious, nursery themes to solidify, and a more specific vision of your future child to take shape.

For many, this is a purely joyful reveal. But for those of us who have navigated the long and often emotionally complex path of infertility, discovering our baby’s sex can sometimes bring with it a surprising layer of nuanced emotions, including, for some, feelings of gender disappointment. This isn't about not wanting this baby; it's often about the gentle (or sometimes not-so-gentle) letting go of a specific dream or preference you might have held, perhaps unconsciously, throughout your years of longing. Here at GrowingMyFamily, we want to create a safe space to acknowledge that all feelings around this reveal are valid, especially when viewed through the lens of your unique journey.

More Than Just Blue or Pink: The Layers of Meaning After Infertility

Why can finding out the baby’s sex feel particularly significant or emotionally complex after infertility?

Heightened Hopes and Dreams: After years of uncertainty, you may have built up very specific visions of your future child, and that vision might have included a particular gender.

The "One Shot" Feeling (Sometimes): If you feel this might be your only child due to past struggles, the desire for a specific gender (perhaps to "balance" a family if you already have a child, or to fulfill a lifelong personal dream) can feel more intense.

Past Losses: If you’ve experienced previous losses, you might have associated a certain gender with a lost pregnancy, leading to complex feelings when faced with a new gender reveal.

Societal or Family Pressures (Subtle or Overt): Sometimes, there are external expectations or desires from family members for a child of a particular sex.

The Desire for a Specific Parent-Child Dynamic: You might have envisioned yourself as a "girl mom" or a "boy dad," or imagined certain activities or relationships based on gender.

Guilt Over Having a Preference at All: This is a big one. After struggling so hard just to get pregnant, you might feel immense guilt for having any preference at all, telling yourself you "should" just be grateful for a healthy baby, regardless of sex. This guilt can make it hard to acknowledge or process any feelings of disappointment if they arise.

The Full Spectrum of Emotions is Okay (Yes, Even Disappointment)

When you find out your baby’s assigned sex at birth, it’s normal to feel a range of emotions. There is no single "right" way to react:

Pure Joy and Excitement: Thrilled with the news, perhaps it aligns perfectly with your hopes, or you simply feel overjoyed to know more about your baby.

Relief: A sense of ease, perhaps feeling like you can now plan more concretely or that a certain anxiety has lifted.

Surprise: Genuinely surprised by the result, perhaps it was different from what you or others guessed.

Gender Disappointment or Sadness: This is a real and valid feeling. It’s a pang of sadness or grief if the result doesn’t match a conscious or unconscious hope or preference you held. It might be fleeting, or it might take some time to process.

Guilt (Often Accompanying Disappointment): Feeling intensely guilty for feeling disappointed, telling yourself you "should" just be grateful to be pregnant at all after infertility. This guilt can be particularly strong and isolating.

Confusion: Feeling confused about why you feel disappointed, especially when you desperately wanted any healthy baby.

Anxiety: Worrying if your disappointment means you won’t bond with the baby, or how to share the news with others if you’re not feeling purely ecstatic.

Numbness or Neutrality: Feeling somewhat detached or unable to process the information immediately, or simply feeling neutral about it.

It is absolutely crucial to understand this: Feeling disappointment about your baby’s sex does NOT make you ungrateful for the pregnancy. It does NOT mean you won’t love your child fiercely and unconditionally. It simply means you had a specific hope or vision that now needs to adjust, and processing that shift takes time, honesty, and self-compassion. The guilt associated with this feeling, especially after the battle of infertility, is incredibly common and deserves to be met with understanding, not judgment.

Navigating Your Feelings with Kindness and Honesty

If you experience gender disappointment, or any complex emotions around this reveal, here are some gentle ways to navigate it:

Acknowledge and Name Your True Feeling (Without Judgment)

Instead of suppressing disappointment or layering it with immediate guilt, try to acknowledge it internally: "Okay, I’m feeling a little sad/disappointed right now that it’s a [boy/girl], and that’s okay. It doesn’t mean I’m not thrilled to be pregnant." Giving the feeling a name can lessen its power.

Allow Yourself Time and Space to Process

These feelings might not vanish overnight. Give yourself permission to sit with the emotion for a while, without forcing immediate acceptance or feigned excitement.

Explore the Roots of Your Preference (Gently)

If you had a strong preference, where did it come from? Was it about specific dreams, past experiences, family dynamics, or societal influences? Understanding the "why" can sometimes help in letting go. Journaling can be helpful here.

Talk About It (with Safe, Non-Judgmental People)

This is key. Share your feelings with a trusted, empathetic person – your partner (if they are supportive and understanding of this specific nuance), a very close friend who "gets it," your therapist, or crucially, within a safe peer support space like the GrowingMyFamily community where others have likely experienced and understand gender disappointment after infertility. Hearing "I felt that way too, and it passed, and I adore my child" can dissolve immense guilt.

Separate the Feeling from Your Future Love for Your Child

Remind yourself, repeatedly if necessary, that feeling disappointed about the sex is entirely different from your capacity to love the individual child who is growing within you. Bonding is a process that unfolds over time, built on connection and care, not on preconceived gender notions.

Challenge the Guilt and "Shoulds"

Gently question the voice that says, "You should only be grateful." It’s okay to be grateful for the pregnancy and have nuanced feelings about specific aspects. You are human.

Focus on the Individual Child You Are Carrying

Try to shift your focus from the abstract idea of "boy" or "girl" to the specific, unique baby growing within you. Think about their movements, anticipate their personality (which is far more than their sex), and focus on your hopes for their health, happiness, and the wonderful individual they will become.

Find Positive Associations and Reframe

Consciously look for the positive aspects, joys, or unique experiences associated with raising a child of the sex you are having. Read positive stories, connect with parents of children of that sex. This can help you build new, positive anticipations.

GrowingMyFamily: A Place for All Your Authentic Feelings

Finding out your baby’s sex is a unique moment in your pregnancy after infertility, capable of bringing great joy or a surprising mix of complex, sometimes guilt-ridden, emotions like gender disappointment. In the GrowingMyFamily community:

We understand that these feelings are real and valid, especially after the intense longing of infertility.

There is no judgment, only support and understanding for the full spectrum of your emotional experience.

We encourage members often share their own journeys with gender preferences and disappointment, offering solidarity and reassurance that these feelings can be processed and that profound love for their child ultimately shines through.

Your Love Will Define Your Bond, Not a Preference

Friend, whatever you feel upon discovering your baby’s sex is okay. Allow yourself the time and space to process any unexpected emotions with honesty and self-compassion. Lean on supportive people who understand the nuances of this journey. And remember, above all, that your love for your child, the child you fought so hard for, will grow in ways you can’t yet imagine, completely transcending any initial preferences. Your feelings are real, they are understood here, and navigating them honestly is part of your unique and beautiful path to parenthood.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Woven Threads: How Parenthood Through Biology and Adoption Shaped Our Hearts for Donor Embryos

The paths to building a family are as varied and intricate as the families themselves. Each journey, with its unique twists and turns, shapes us, teaches us, and expands our hearts in ways we might never have anticipated. My own path to the family I cherish today has been woven with distinct, yet beautifully interconnected threads: first, the experience of biological motherhood, then the profound journey of adopting our three children, welcoming another biological child and later, the path of welcoming our two younger sons through the use of donated embryos. It's this rich tapestry of experiences, particularly the deep lessons learned as an adoptive mom, that I believe uniquely prepared my heart and mind for embracing motherhood again through donor embryos. It wasn't about one path being "better" or "easier," but about how each experience informed the next, deepening our understanding of what family truly means. If you're navigating your own complex path...

When Fear Gives Way to Family

Hey there friend! Let's talk about how much things can change. If someone had told me nearly fifteen years ago, when our family was just beginning its adoption journey, what our life would look like today, I would have probably laughed. Or cried. Or both. The person I was back then… I almost cringe thinking about her. She thought she knew everything about how to be a good adoptive parent. The truth is, I had no idea. It feels vulnerable to admit that, but maybe you understand. Maybe you’ve had moments on your own journey where you look back at a past version of yourself with a strange mix of embarrassment and compassion. The things I was so sure of then have been quietly, gently replaced over the years. They've been replaced by a deeper understanding—an understanding that came from listening, really listening, to other adoptive parents, and most importantly, to adult adoptees themselves. Their wisdom has been my greatest teacher, showing me what our kids truly need, the importa...

The Day Our Family Expanded at a Tim Hortons

Some moments in life are so pivotal, so charged with emotion and anticipation, that they etch themselves into your memory with vivid clarity. For us, one such moment unfolded on a Thursday afternoon in May. The setting was unassuming: a corner table at a Tim Hortons. But what happened there wasn't just a meeting; it was the beginning of a new chapter, the day our family story expanded in the most beautiful and unexpected way. It was the day we first met our younger sons' genetic parents. Our journey to this Tim Hortons table had been, like so many of yours, one filled with hope, longing, and the unique path of donor conception. We had chosen to build our family using donor embryos—a decision we made with careful thought and immense gratitude. We knew, intellectually, that this meeting was important, a step towards the open and honest family we envisioned. But nothing quite prepared us for the emotions of that afternoon. There was a nervousness, of course. What would they be lik...